Monday, February 18, 2008

Pasts keep intersecting 

This incredible non-story about the Clinton campaign charging Obama with "plagiarizing" a portion of his speeches from Deval Patrick is stupifying.

As TPM commenter cswartout noted, the media already covered the similarities in their rhetoric 10 months ago. It's not like this is some big mystery. Not only are Obama and Patrick friends, but they have used the same media strategist: David Axelrod. That should explain a lot.

What's interesting, though, is that Obama first used the quote in question as a criticism of Saul Alinsky, the famous radical Chicago community organizer. (Hillary Clinton's college thesis analyzed Alinsky's tactics.)

An intriguing and revealing 2007 TNR profile of Obama quoted him as saying:

Alinsky understated the degree to which people's hopes and dreams and their ideals and their values were just as important in organizing as people's self-interest. Sometimes the tendency in community organizing of the sort done by Alinsky was to downplay the power of words and of ideas when in fact ideas and words are pretty powerful. We hold these truths to be self-evident, all men are created equal.' Those are just words. I have a dream.' Just words. But they help move things. And I think it was partly that understanding that probably led me to try to do something similar in different arenas."


In a comment to an earlier post, YRHT compatriot joejoejoe pointed us to this essay by Obama that discusses community organizing in the inner city, "After Alinsky".

Labels: ,

2 comments DiggIt! Del.icio.us

2 Comments:

This non-story is a major reason why I've never been a fan of either Hillary or Bill Clinton. It's just the sort of thing you'd expect from the Republicans...with the exception of a media amen-chorus to really play it up.

By Blogger Michael, at 10:53 AM  

Man, the Clintons continue to fall in my regard. Desperate times and all that. It reminds me of a column by Gregg Easterbrooke a few years ago about political people collaborating with a ghost writer whose name is in micro-font while "Clinton" is huge at the top. When you know who did the actual writing. Here Obama actually writes his own books, and he gets static on something like this. One of the things I like the best about him so far is how he takes the shots in stride (with defusing humor with just the right amount of bite). A reassuring sign for those who don't think he's tough enough to stand up to the Repubs!

By Anonymous HammHawk, at 1:28 PM